Customer reviews
2.47 out of 5stars
(30 reviews)
Most helpful positive review
5.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
02/24/2022
Now these are EXTRA TOASTY - Thanks
I was surprised to see the volume of comments regarding peoples' expectations for Extra Toasty Cheez Its. We've gotten a few boxes that are spot on so far as our expectations go. We thought we'd share some pics. Thank you.
Mrpete
Most helpful negative review
1.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
11/19/2022
Burnt is not toasty
Have you ever eaten popcorn or crackers and ate one that was slightly more cooked than the rest? It's a whole new level of delicious, right? That's not these. These are burnt and flavorless. ZERO flavor except burnt bitterness. These sucked the life out of my mouth leaving no moisture in their wake. All with no discernable salt on top of the cracker. The cheese flavor I expected was non-existent. In my opinion, an incredibly bad product. Not one person in our household, even slightly, enjoyed these. Returning them.
Jan
14 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
-
3.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser08/16/2023Not so toastyWhen extra toasty first came out, I was so excited. In the last year, unfortunately, the extra toasty crackers are far and few like an original cheeze it cracker. The flavors are still amazing, but I am sure I speak for most toasty eaters, we want them extra extra toasty.E
-
3.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser08/06/2023Extra toasty, aren't extra toasty.They are good if they are really toasty, even burnt a little. I've been disappointed. One in ten boxes are extra toasty. Just disappointing, and really a tasty treat.None
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser08/03/2023Extra toasty cheez itCheez its are my go too love them but the last 3-4 boxes i have purchased of the extra toasty cheez its have almost no salt on them. The box i have right now has a speck or two but the last couple boxes there was no trace of salt. It really sucks it takes a huge hit on their taste their just bland.Britt18
-
5.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser07/26/2023A
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser07/14/2023Worst snack ever inventedHuge fan of Cheez-It so I thought I'd give these a try. These are the worst crackers every invented. Who thought selling burnt crackers was a good idea? Hardly any salt or cheese flavor.Christy
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser07/10/2023Immediate disgust for a product I once loved!!!WOW! I have ordered these numerous times and they were Great until I got one of the “burned up boxes of the crackers.” They were beyond NASTY . My apologies to my fellow customers who I thought were pulling pranks. HOW can you think it's ok to package your screw up and sell it anyway? How selfish!Doris
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser02/08/2023Thumbs down from my kiddosI am a Daycare Lead Teacher. My four year old do NOT like extra toasted. They did try them but didn't finish their snack. We prefer Regular Cheese It's.Midiwalk
-
5.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser12/28/2022I eat too manyI tried the extra toasty and have been hooked on them ever since! They're hard to find in most grocery stores and one time I settled for the regular Cheez It and they're not as 'crispy' and flavorful. Always happy when Walmart has them in stock.christine
-
4.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser12/19/2022Very very goodI have ate cheez it's for over 40years and have enjoyed them very much. The extra toasty one's are my favorite now... didn't think I would ever change up... Right On!!!!!Jerry
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser11/19/2022Burnt is not toastyHave you ever eaten popcorn or crackers and ate one that was slightly more cooked than the rest? It's a whole new level of delicious, right? That's not these. These are burnt and flavorless. ZERO flavor except burnt bitterness. These sucked the life out of my mouth leaving no moisture in their wake. All with no discernable salt on top of the cracker. The cheese flavor I expected was non-existent. In my opinion, an incredibly bad product. Not one person in our household, even slightly, enjoyed these. Returning them.Jan
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser09/13/2022Mutilated BoxThis was part of a delivery order. This is the exact conditon the box was delivered in. How and why?Kelli
-
3.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser08/19/2022Sometimes extra toastyNot always extra toasty...... I requested about 10 years ago or more for a more done cheezit .... I suggested Cajun or darker cheez it.... They took the idea ..... But seem to have a problem making sure extra toasty cheez it's get in the box... But when they do they are AWESOME...Vickster
-
3.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser05/31/2022Not Toasty!I love the ones that are super burnt so the “Extra Toasty” made that a reality! Unfortunately, I have gotten what seems to be “Original” Cheezeits the past couple buys. Sad!TB
-
4.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser03/21/2022Absolutely love these!Fantastic flavor! I love these so much, unfortunately I've gotta say it; lately the toastiness has been heavily lacking. The past 3 boxes I've been digging through just for the toasty ones and leaving the rest. Just saying, don't be afraid to turn up the heat a bit! Let em all get that toasty brown. Overall though, great product and it's a must have with very shopping list.Alex
-
4.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser03/07/2022Amazing when they are actually toasty.I agree with others that lately they haven't been as extra toasty as usual. I go to the grocery store and hover my hand over each box to grab the one that “feels” toastiest. Regular cheez its are for the non-toasty lovers, I want mine to look like it fell asleep while sunbathing. Photo of an (almost) perfect cheez it:BurntToastLover
-
5.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser02/24/2022Now these are EXTRA TOASTY - ThanksI was surprised to see the volume of comments regarding peoples' expectations for Extra Toasty Cheez Its. We've gotten a few boxes that are spot on so far as our expectations go. We thought we'd share some pics. Thank you.Mrpete
-
2.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser02/06/2022Extra toasty not good anymoreI loved the extra toasty cheezit's however, something has changed over the last couple months. The boxes I have bought are not as toasty as before. They also don't have much salt on top making them inedible. I waited a few weeks thinking it was a bad batch but the latest box I purchased is also inedible. Think it might be time to change snacks.Cuban66604
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser12/11/2021Worst Cheez-ItsRecently bought a box of extra toasty Cheez-Its and had no idea how awful they are until I opened the box and found burnt crackers! Had no idea extra toasty meant they'd be burned crackers! I'll have to pay better attention to what I'm purchasing in the future.Suz
-
1.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser11/19/2021Not very Toasty :(I love the extra Toasty Cheez-its but they are getting hard to find. There are tons of boxes of them at the store but only 1 out if 3 boxes is actually toasty. The majority of the boxes are just like the regular Cheez-its but stale. Very disappointing.friedMacaroni
-
3.00 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchaser09/19/2021Bad, burnt crackersBought by mistake. These are just the overcooked crackers the company probably used to throw away. Now they figured out a way to get people to pay for them! Wish they would make the box easier to identify so I wont keep buying them by accident. Yuck!Lynn