One Bite

Barstool Sports One Bite 5 Cheese Frozen Pizza 12" 20.11 oz

$4.74
(3.4) 3.4 stars out of 20 reviews 20 reviews
$4.74
$4.74
Free overnigh delivery
FSA and HSA eligible
Barstool Sports One Bite 5 Cheese Frozen Pizza 12" 20.11 oz

Notice unusual marketplace activity?

Report

Customer reviews & ratings

3.4 out of 5stars
(20 reviews)
See all reviews

Most helpful positive review

5.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
02/19/2022
Great Frozen Pizza!
Mozzarella, Cheddar, Provolone Fontina and Parmesan, the combination of these five cheeses creates such a delicious flavor! The sauce tastes fresh and well-seasoned without being salty or overpowering. The crust is crispy and perfect! I left the pizza in the oven for 5 minutes more than instructed on the box because I prefer mine well-done. Highly recommended!
Mona

Most helpful negative review

1.00 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchaser
12/14/2021
Cheap dough and disgusting smell/taste
This pizza is awful. It's a simple dough, similar to the microwave pizzas. The main problem is that it smells ... and there's no other way to say this, it smells like vomit. With that smell in your face when you go to take a bite, who can even taste if it's good? Spoiler... it is not good.
Dina
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    03/11/2022
    5 Star Pizza!
    After reading other reviews I had low expectations for this pizza. Loved it! I got the 5 Cheese pizza to try. Baked it according to the package directions for 13 minutes. Instructions said to bake it for 10-13 minutes. The crust is thin and airy, and after 13 minutes a bit crunchy as I prefer. Hate thin floppy crust pizzas! The sauce had a nice flavor, not too sweet or spicy. Most frozen pizzas skimp on the cheese, but not this brand. Perfect amount of flavorful gooey cheese. The price of the pizza is less than some of the big name brands, which is fine by me! For flavor, it beats out most of the competition. I don't understand why there are so many negative reviews. I am a huge pizza lover! And a bit of a pizza snob... I will buy it again! 5 Stars!
    nkw123
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    03/05/2022
    The Cheese
    The best part is definitely the cheese. It's very good! Every family member enjoyed it. Because I'm a little more picky, I didn't like that other than the cheese there was not a lot of sauce flavor and the crust was just ok. The crust had it's moment with perfection of mouth feel with the softness under the cheese, but crispy crunchy on the bottom. In a world of frozen pizzas and comparing with the price I, personally, would not pick this particular one. My kids just loved it though!
    Christiny
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/28/2022
    Great crust
    I cooked up this pizza for my family for dinner. The topping coverage was pretty loose in the package, and I had to rearrange a few of the pieces before baking so I could get an even coverage. I followed the directions, baking it for the full amount of time since I like it a bit crunchier rather than softer. The result was perfect. The cheese was melted and slightly brown and bubbling. I liked that the toppings went close to the crust, especially since I have kids that would rather not eat plain crust. We were all impressed with the texture and taste of the crust. It was airy and chewy, almost like a fresh-made crust, which you don't expect from a frozen pizza. The toppings were pretty standard. Nothing that stood out, but that crust was fantastic. Overall, it was a hit with this family.
    KRay
  • 1.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/28/2022
    It was still raw inside.
    This frozen pizza was a good price (about $5.50) so I decided to give it a try. It said to cook 10-13 minutes. At 10 we took it out but it was still raw inside. I put in back in for 3 more minutes. It still did not looked cooked all the way. I put it in for 5 more minutes, until the cheese was very brown and I feared if I put it in for any longer, the cheese would be completely burnt too. So I took it out after 18 minutes. The cheese tasted fine. The sauce is nothing special. It tasted like most other frozen pizza's. No one would ever mistake this for a delivered pizza. But the worst thing is that I could not get the inside to cook. After 18 minutes, there was still a line of raw dough near the bottom crust.
    CbuOhio
  • 2.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/26/2022
    Just Average Pizza with Good Crust Edge
    This is a review for the Barstool Sports One Bite five cheese stone baked crust pizza. This pizza is 20.11 Oz. It has five different cheeses including mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, fontina and parmesan cheese. It is a 12-inch Pizza that is 330 calories for 1/4 of the pizza, or 1,320 Cal for the entire pizza. The instructions state to pre-heat your oven to 450 degrees and place pizza directly on the middle rack. Second, it says to bake it for 10-13 minutes or until the edge of crust is golden brown and the cheese is melted. Lastly it says to let stand two to three minutes before slicing. I found that 11 minutes was the perfect time for it to cook. I turned it around at 7 minutes and then cooked it for another 4 minutes. For some reason this pizza was hard to turn around in the oven, so I suggest taking it out onto a baking sheet or the cardboard package and then turning around and putting it back in. The interesting thing about the crust is that it is crunchy on the outside but soft on the inside. After cooking you for 11 minutes it is plenty cooked on the edges, but a little softer in the middle. There is always the option to possibly put it on the bottom shelf for a minute or two at the end of baking if you want the bottom of the crust to be a little darker and crunchier. I love how crunchy the outside crust is, however I am not overly impressed with this pizza. The cheese seemed to be very light when I opened the package, so I'm not tasting much of the cheese flavor. The sauce does not seem to be great quality even though it does have some spices in it, in fact I thought it was just ordinary. Adding a little salt on top does enhance the flavor, which I like, however I would not go out of my way to buy this pizza. The only benefit this pizza has is the crunchiness of the crust edges; the crunchiness of this crust edge makes it seem like a better pizza because most pizza crusts do not have such a great crust crunch. I wish the sauce was tastier and had more of a marinara or pizza sauce flavor, but it seems bland. The cheese amount should have been doubled, as you can see the given amount in the picture. Overall I do not recommend this pizza.
    Kiasumsam
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/25/2022
    Nice, fresh pizza
    This is a review of the One Bite Supreme Stone Baked Crust pizza. The meat and vegetable toppings were all fresh and baked up well. The pizza dough was similar to a flatbread, both crunchy and chewy. No dry or tasteless crust edges. I ate the whole slice. The taste was very good overall. I thought a smidge bland so I added garlic salt and it was perfect. I would recommend.
    Maxi
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/25/2022
    Delicious
    This pizza is very delicious. The crust is probably the best I've ever had. It is super soft but still pretty thick. Toppings on 5 cheese pizza are pretty greasy but that's not a bad thing at all. After all, it's cheese and pizza :) I usually only eat red baron pizzas because I haven't found anything that's as good but these really are! I definitely recommend!
    Kat
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/21/2022
    MM Good!
    I didn't see the cheese pizza, so I tried the Barstool Sports One Bite Supreme Frozen Pizza. This is a delicious frozen pizza. The toppings are a great quality, and plenty of them. My spouse took 5 slices of the pepperoni off the pizza. There was no need though. The pepperoni was great tasting and didn't leave little pockets of grease like some frozen pizza. The pizza is cooked directly on the oven rack. The top, and bottom cooked up evenly. I didn't have to burn my edges waiting for the middle of the pizza to finish cooking. It has a crispy bite, and a good tasting crust. We liked the large slices of red, and green peppers. The fresh tasting/nongreasy pepperoni. The small but plenty of good tasting sausage. But, we really liked the chunky red onion slices. Red onion adds great flavor to whatever it is put on. The great taste, and fresh toppings made up for the reduced amount of sauce. The cheese was ok. It passed all the taste test: baked, cold, and reheated in the air fryer. Overall, Barstool Sports pizza has a fresh, great tasting pizza. Other flavors we plan to try are Five Cheese, Pepperoni, and Three Meat.
    Rocky
  • 5.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/19/2022
    Great Frozen Pizza!
    Mozzarella, Cheddar, Provolone Fontina and Parmesan, the combination of these five cheeses creates such a delicious flavor! The sauce tastes fresh and well-seasoned without being salty or overpowering. The crust is crispy and perfect! I left the pizza in the oven for 5 minutes more than instructed on the box because I prefer mine well-done. Highly recommended!
    Mona
  • 4.00 out of 5 stars review
    Verified Purchaser
    02/18/2022
    Better than most
    I eat frozen pizza approximately once a week, and when I saw this, I was pretty excited to try it. Disclaimer: I much prefer a thin crust pizza over the thick stuff that is most prevalent in the supermarkets now. I also prefer to add my own toppings, so I always buy the cheese pizza. I got two pizzas - on different days - and each one looked pretty different, as far as cheese coverage and length of shred cut. The main attractions for a frozen pizza for me are the crust, the sauce, and - to a degree - the cheese. I'll add cheese anyway, so that's not a deal breaker. Never have found a frozen pizza with good meat toppings in 30 years of frozen pizza eating, so I've long given up on that. I add my own. In order to give a fair review, I decided to cook this as directed on the box - in the oven - rather than with my pizza cooker. As directed, I preheated the oven to 450 and placed the pizza, with my added toppings, on the center rack. It was suggested to cook the pizza for 10 to 13 minutes, and I immediately set for 13 because I like my pizza fully cooked. At the 13 minute mark, the pizza looked like it had been thawed and warmed, but nowhere near done. As with every pizza I've ever tried to cook with a conventional oven, the edges were done long before the center was. Photo is at the 17 minute mark. I finished off the center on my pizza cooker. I DO NOT blame this pizza for that; 20+ years, and several homes, and every oven has always yielded the same results, which is why I own a pizza cooker in the first place. Now to the most important part: how does the pizza taste? In brief? Pretty darn good. The dough is docked (pierced with little holes), which allows the crust to crisp up nicely. Advertised as ‘stone-baked', and that seems about right. Not sure if the attached photo shows it well, but the cross-section of the crust is very bread-like. Very impressive. A little thicker than I'd like, but very crunchy and has a good taste and texture. One of the best that I've tried, and I've tried pretty much everything out there. If you're looking for that NY Style foldable slice, maybe put this on a high rack on a baking sheet, because baked as directed, the crust is awesomely crispy and absolutely unfoldable. As for flavor? Meh. The addition of some basil, garlic, and oregano may have helped. No zing or zest, but that may be intentional, to appeal to the entire family. The crust tasted a little charred, which is also probably intentional. Not a bad thing. I chose the 5 Cheese version, and added a bit of mozzarella of my own, but I certainly didn't get hints of different cheeses. Kinda like M&Ms having different colors, but all are the exact same flavor. I guess adding spices isn't that difficult, and it's quite possible that other topping versions have a spicier taste. I'm kinda itching to try another one of these prepared on my Pizza Pizzazz, and maybe one on a gas grill. Costs about the same as the ‘Rising Crust' version of the national brand that compares itself to ‘delivery', and that's completely fair. Did this completely blow my socks off to the point where I'd serve this when I have guests over, rather than order carryout? Nope. No frozen pizza that I've ever tried has. Bottom line? This is a better-than-average frozen pizza at a fair price.
    JustDave
See all reviews